42

42

way so as to give a vast multitude of different one to one
relations. Among these different relations there must
be some all of whose correlates are A's because
every possible variation of our relation occurs, and
they could not all agree in any respect unless it
were logically compelled. But since we are going
on the hypothesis that every one of these relations
leaves some A that is not a correlate, it follows
that there is nothing to compel any correlate
to be non-A; for the only logical requirement is
that no two correlates shall be identical and since
even when we do not care whether they are so
or not there are A's that are non-correlates, it
follows that there is nothing to compel any correlate to
be a non-A, since there are A's that it may be